US History - Supreme Court Cases - Part 20
Comparative Analysis
One way of analyzing is by using Comparative Analysis or simply put Compare and Contrast. Comparing is done by finding the Similarities and Differences between two (2) or more historical events/ideas/people/developments. Contrasting is only finding the Differences.
You can analyze a specific topic by highlighting the similarities and differences. How they are similar and how they are different. A Venn Diagram is usually used as a graphic organizer for this purpose. You may use this Venn Diagram Worksheet for Similarities and Differences or a T-Chart to list differences.
When writing, most of the time when you change your topic, you should start a new paragraph. For a Comparative Analysis essay, one paragraph would explain in detail the first topic, as well as the other topic. You achieve the comparative analysis by comparing categories that are the same, or in other words "like" or "unlike" things.
For example, if you are comparing the economic philosophies of Adam Smith and Karl Marx, you would write "Adam Smith was the father of capitalism while Karl Marx was the father of communism." Then you would explain further by writing; "Capitalism is the belief in private property whereas communism is the belief that there is no private property". And then explain; "In Smith's economic system of capitalism the government's hands are off the economy which is called laissez-faire or free market capitalism. This is in opposition to Marx's economic system of communism in which the economy is controlled by the state. This is called a command economy."
The back and forth characteristics of comparative analysis is necessary for it to be considered analysis. You are consistently comparing one aspect of your discussion with another aspect of your discussion or fact verses fact.
Comparative Analysis Writing Instructions
Directions:
1. Your task is to choose Two (2) of the Landmark Supreme Court Cases and complete a Comparative Analysis essay.
2. In the Introduction, explain the basic working of the Federal Court System including the Supreme Court.
3. In the Body Paragraphs, choose two (2) of the Landmark Supreme Court Cases and explain the Historical Circumstances that led to each case, AND
complete a Comparative Analysis essay. (for details on how to complete the analysis, please refer to the guide above)
4. In the conclusion, explain the concepts of Judicial Activism vs. Judicial Restraint, AND
for the Landmark Supreme Court Cases, evaluate and explain how one of those concepts apply to each case.
Landmark Cases Chart
